Re: Combat Point Value Revisited

***
>Should you have a single-value CPV when it can, at best, be a guide?

IMHO it's better than not having one. In cases other than the extreme
ones it does a pretty decent job; and although I don't fight
even-point-value battles I still find it useful for evaluating how well
the players did relative to each other.
***

Both questions semi-rhetorical. ;->=

I certainly agree that a point system, the better the better, and on
this
all give a shout out to OO, is not merely 'nice', but vital to some
people.
However, you do have to beat some people over the head with 'even the
Evil
Empire's system breaks down at certain points' without arcane and
arbitrary
rules.

The_Beast