Base Sizes (was Re: Re: [GZG] New game mechanics (was: Re: Name for Rules))

Hi Allan,

Flames of War basing is 32mm x 25mm (1 1/4"x 1") for 1 - 3 miniatures
and 
50mm x 32mm (2" x 1 1/4") for infantry teams of 4 - 5 minatures, and 
man-packed gun teams.

I have some 15mm GZG fire teams based up on FoW sized bases and as an 
experiment I've taken photos of them and some unpainted minis on 30mm x
30mm 
and 25mm x 25mm paper bases as a comparison.  If you'd like a look at
the 
photos (assuming they come out ;) ), let me know and I'll e-mail them to

you.

I'd avoid 25mm x 25mm bases as the figures only just fit on (and then
you 
may have to trim the metal bases) and look crowded.  Things aren't much 
better on 30mm x 30mm - there isn't much room to even pretend that
they're 
modern infantry advancing in open order.  The FoW bases are an odd size
(you 
could probably get away with going to a 40mm x 30mm base) but, as others

have suggested, unless the base size is crucial to ground scale, then 
measuring distances from the centre of the base, or from some
recognizable 
feature of the base, may be the way to go and to heck with the actual
base 
size.

David

> Subject: Re: [GZG] New game mechanics (was: Re: Name for Rules)
> To: gzg-l@lists.csua.berkeley.edu
> Message-ID:
> <e905d33f0611032035j1de08cd5v7ff869e462f9d8d9@mail.gmail.com>
> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1; format=flowed
>
> On 11/3/06, Mark Kinsey <Kinseym@ptd.net> wrote:
>>
>> First basing. I'm cool with any base size between 1" by 1" and the
FOW
>> base sizes. Some people like Stuart Murray use old GZG figs and Peter
>> Pig which are "true 15's and they fit just fine on a 25mm x 25mm
base,
>> IMHO the current GZG minis fit better on a 30 x 30mm base (for a 3 to
4
>> man team) By way of information, the
>> FOW small bases are 32mm x 25mm and their medium bases are 50mm x
32mm.
>> I think it's a matter of personal taste and the rules should be
flexible
>> on this point.
>
> I did a quick check of other rules I have to see how they handle base 
> sizes.
>
> There aren't many games in the scale proposed for
> SG3/SG:AC/G-Cav/whatever it ends up being called. That is, most sci-fi
> games are either individual figure bases, or they are 6mm.
>
> The old Striker rules suggests that figures should be on bases 1" by
> 1". That's all I have in my collection that comes close to SG3.
>
> I checked Crossfire, Bases in Crossfire are 1.25" by 1.25", which
> translates to Mark's 30mm by 30mm suggestion.
>
> Out of curiousity, I checked Piquet's base sizes. They are 1.5" by
> 0.75" for infantry squads. Call it 40mm by 20mm.
>
> Unless there is a game reason for squads to be wider than they are
> deep, I'd go with a square base for infantry. 30mm by 30mm works for
> me for 15mm. You can scale it down to 20mm by 20mm for 10mm figures,
> or 15mm by 15mm for 6mm figures and 50mm by 50mm (call it 2 inches
> square) for 25mm through 30mm figures.
>
> Allan
>
> -- 
> Allan Goodall 	   http://www.hyperbear.com
> agoodall@hyperbear.com
> awgoodall@gmail.com
>
> 

_______________________________________________
Gzg-l mailing list
Gzg-l@lists.csua.berkeley.edu
http://lists.csua.berkeley.edu/mailman/listinfo/gzg-l