Re: Re: Re: [GZG] Revised Salvo Missiles Update

[Oerjan Ariander <oerjan.ariander@xxxxxxxxx>]

John Tailby wrote:

> Why would range of engagement with a missile affect it's chance of a 
> hit?  I can see situations where missiles have a harder chance locking on 
> up close than they do at a distance. Missile chance to hit would likely be 
> a function of sensor lock from parent ship - ECM with distance a neutral 
> factor.

In reality, you mean? The longer the missile has to fly to reach its target 
the more time the target's ECM has to break its target lock and/or simply 
outmanoeuvre the missile; and the farther away the the missile's parent 
ship is from the target, the greater the time lag on its sensor returns 
becomes and the less up-to-date the targetting data the parent ship can 
send to the missile will be. Distance is far from neutral for missile 
engagements.

> What feel do you want with your missiles?
> If you use a couple of 20 century models as examples.
> If you want the game to feel like 20C naval warfare then your missile 
> speed / engagement envelope needs to be much larger than the speed of the 
> ships. Missiles lauched today are thousands of times faster than the speed 
> of a warship

Er... if you used a little less hyperbole and shaved a zero or two off from 
that "thousands", your example would probably be more convincing.

A missile "thousands of times faster" than the warship it is targetting 
would fly at speeds of Mach 50+ (at sea level, since that's where most of 
today's warships tend to be located). Not even solid anti-tank projectiles 
can fly that fast without melting within a fraction of a second...

Actual anti-ship missile speeds today are generally in the Mach 0.5 - 3 
range; the fastest Russian supersonic ship-killers might go up to Mach 5, 
but that's *really* extreme.

IOW, typical missiles today fly 10-50 times faster than the ships they are 
targetting. Still a big difference compared to the anti-air situation where 
missiles could even be *slower* than their would-be targets on occasion, 
but the gap to direct-fire weapons is even larger.

Regards,

Oerjan
oerjan.ariander@xxxxxxxxx

"Life is like a sewer.
 What you get out of it, depends on what you put into it."
-Hen3ry

_______________________________________________
Gzg-l mailing list
Gzg-l@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://lists.csua.berkeley.edu/mailman/listinfo/gzg-l