Re: [GZG] Re: Mines

["john tailby" <John_Tailby@xxxxxxxxxx>]

----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Mike Hillsgrove" <mikeah@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>

> Modern Mines are floating (or anchored on bottom) torpedo tubes with a
> sensor package.  When a target meeting parameters is detected, the torp is
> launched. No reason that a Futuristic "mine" could not detect and not 
> launch
> at an friendly IFF response.  No reason to assume that a mine doesn't have
> the same range that any torp from any ship has.  This gives the minefield 
> an
> incredible reach - as it would today if sea control mines were ever
> deployed.
A modern torpedo has a range of a few kilometres and without the wire 
guidance from a submarines it has to rely on its own active sonar to acquire 
its target. If you would want to deny an area of the pacific ocean to the 
enemy you would need millions of mines. Most mines are located in narrow 
choke points of land and are designed to attack shipping. Trying to deny a 3 
dimensional area against submarine, shipping and air targets required the 
weapons system to have a much greater capability than is current.

In game terms it also comes down to detection range. If mines have the same 
sensor capabilities as starships then they can engage at starship type 
ranges. However this makes the mines expensive to build and deploy and 
capable of counter detection by the ship. The ship loses nothing by not 
scanning with active sensors and or scouting with fighter groups if defence 
are suspected.

Its most likely that mines would have smaller sensors than a ship ( only so 
much you can pack on a mine). So a torpedo would have a much smaller attack 
and detection range than the ship.

In game terms, do the missiles get initial guidance and vectoring from the 
launch vessel and only their terminal guidance (the 6" attack move) is due 
to onboard sensors or does the missile have the detection capability of the 
starship?

The idea I like  to trap an area would be to bait it. Either you can bait 
the area with sensor emissions and transmissions. A mayday call or 2 would 
do nicely and then once you have the enemy vessel in the middle of the field 
you hit them with EMP or needle beams and direct fire weapons. You EMP the 
engines so they can't leave and then cut down the ship. Ideally something 
that kills the crew would be best. Then you have more bait for the next 
ship. The greedy / inquisitive some up at a nice slow speed to board the 
derelict vessel and then the mines attack.

Because you control the enemy movements you don't need so many mines.

John 


_______________________________________________
Gzg-l mailing list
Gzg-l@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://lists.csua.berkeley.edu/mailman/listinfo/gzg-l