Prev: Re: [SG2] Cover Penetration Question for all you Armour Experts Next: RE: [SG2] Cover Penetration Question for all you Armour Experts

[SG2] Fire Team Casualties Question, for the Experts

From: Allan Goodall <agoodall@a...>
Date: Wed, 28 Aug 2002 15:32:21 -0500
Subject: [SG2] Fire Team Casualties Question, for the Experts

I'm working on a set of fire team rules for SG2. I have a question about
casualties.

When a platoon in a modern army using fire teams, such as the US army,
takes
casualties, how is the platoon restructured after the battle? Let's say,
for
the sake of argument, that there were 10% or fewer casualties. Do the
fire
teams maintain their original personnel? Or are fire teams/squads that
took
casualties "cannibalized" to bring up the strength of other fire
teams/squads
that have been reduced by casualties? If a "standard" fire team has 4
soldiers, what is the lowest number of soldiers needed to make a
"viable" fire
team?

The reason I'm asking is that the SG2 rule book includes rules for
calculating
the size of units as if they had taken casualties. (See "Under-Strength
Units", page 10). It's possible that a squad of 9 soldiers could be
reduced
to, say, 6. I'm curious how they would be organized. Would the emphasis
be to
balance the fire teams evenly? Or would they operate as one over-sized
fire
team of 5 plus a squad leader? Would the fire teams receive transfers
from
another squad to build up a fire team to 4 men each, if possible?

On one hand, I can see drills requiring a certain number of troops and
certain
types of equipment in each fire team. On the other, I can see wanting to
maintain fire team integrity as soldiers live and train with the same
people
in their squads. 

My guess would be that if a platoon of 4 squads, 9 per squad (ignoring
command
and support elements) were reduced from 36 to 32 soldiers, the tendancy
would
be to organize them as 3 squads of 9 (1 SL, 2 fire teams of 2), and the
other
5 would form a squad of one SL and one fire team. I would also guess
that if
they were to drop to 28 soldiers, they would form 2 squads of 9 and one
squad
of 10. But, this is just a guess, which is why I'm asking.

Allan Goodall		       agoodall@hyperbear.com
http://www.hyperbear.com

"We come into the world and take our chances
 Fate is just the weight of circumstances
 That's the way that Lady Luck dances


Prev: Re: [SG2] Cover Penetration Question for all you Armour Experts Next: RE: [SG2] Cover Penetration Question for all you Armour Experts