Re: [OT?] Indigenous insurgencies
From: Chen-Song Qin <cqin@e...>
Date: Wed, 30 Sep 1998 15:56:57 -0600 (MDT)
Subject: Re: [OT?] Indigenous insurgencies
I think we're talking about insurgencies in general. These are
basically
revolutions against despotic, weak, and/or unpopular governments. So
the
examples I gave would count. Minority guerrila movements are usually
simply labelled "terrorism"; the ones that are popular and successful
are labelled "revolutions" :)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----
Even the engineers are not *this* depraved. This must be the work of
the
Med. students.
- A friend of mine
------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----
On Wed, 30 Sep 1998, Jonathan Jarrard wrote:
> Sorry to jump in, but do those really count as insurgencies? There's
a
> big difference between leading a revolution in the middle of a power
> vacuum or chaos, and leading a successful guerilla war against a
stable
> government that has at least a large portion of the populace's
support.
>
> Lots of revolutions, coups, and such succeed when a government has
> failed to satisfy 'enough of the right people' (to massively
paraphrase
> Machiavelli). I think the point is that minority-inspired guerilla
> movements have seldom managed to achieve more than banditry without
> outside support.
>